|
Obligatory Villagers | 
 enlarge | Artist: Nellie Mckay
Label: Vanguard Records
Category: Music
Buy New: $16.98
New (33) Used (13) from $6.85
Rating:  20 reviews
Sales Rank: 18837
Format: Explicit Lyrics
Media: Audio CD
Discs: 1
Shipping Weight (lbs): 0.2
Dimensions (in): 5.6 x 5 x 0.5
MPN: 79843
UPC: 015707984324
EAN: 0015707984324
ASIN: B000UDUN2W
Release Date: September 25, 2007
Shipping: Eligible for Super Saver Shipping
Promotion: Save $10.00 when you spend $50.00 or more on Qualifying Items offered by Amazon.com. Enter code BMLSAVES at checkout. Terms and Conditions
Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours
| |
| Tracks:
| • | Mother of Pearl | | • | Oversure | | • | Gin Rummy | | • | Livin | | • | Identity Theft | | • | Galleon | | • | Politan | | • | Testify | | • | Zombie |
|
| Similar Items:
|
| Editorial Reviews:
Product Description
Nellie McKay returns with Obligatory Villagers, a 9-song odyssey and follow-up to Pretty little head, one of the best-reviewed records of 2006. Like its predecessor, Villagers produced, arranged, written and performed by Nellie, this time featuring an ensemble of jazz greats, including Phil Woods, Dave Liebman and Bob Dorough. An early review from Pitchfork testifies, from the cheeky ukulele-and-tap-shoes dance break! in the middle of album opener Mother of Pearl to the chorus of brain-hungry zombies on a finale titled, yes, Zombie , Villagers finds Nellie and her collaborators at their most lively and rambunctious.
|
| Customer Reviews: Read 15 more reviews...
 excellent! October 12, 2008
Great music and lyrics. Nellie McKay has phenomenal insight and style. Her music is diverse, validating, and inspiring! She has an amazing voice and wit, and her creativity knows no bounds.
 Peaks and Valleys August 19, 2008
Ms. McKay has both a tremendous amount of talent and energy. Her voice is rather ordinary, but her musicianship is wonderful. Her lyric writing is sometimes brilliant and sometimes amateurish. often all within the same song.
Obligatory Villagers is to my ear probably her best CD so far with less low spots and excess than her previous CDs. But I think and know she can do better.
My view is that Ms. McKay needs someone like a modern day Norman Ganz to harness her immense talent into something that all can enjoy. Right now there is a lot of quirky stuff and brilliance mixed with material that's just plain dopey. It's music for audiophiles.
I don't think Columbia was the right place for her, but this do it yourself approach she's using now desperately needs an editor. She needs to find an outside ear she trusts to help her refine her sound and approach. I hope that this happens eventually.
Great Subversive Potential April 20, 2008
3 out of 4 found this review helpful
Nellie McKay has received a lot of positive press, but the further west you get of, say, Greenwich Village, the less well known she is. So I bought this c.d., way out west, with some degree of anticipation.
And the anticipation was fulfilled, and then some, on the opening number, "Mother of Pearl." Is this a slap at feminism, or a slap at those who would slap at feminism? Judging by the tag line, "I'm Dennis Kucinich, and I approve this message," I'm guessing the latter. Whichever, it's sharply written and nicely pulled off.
From there, IMO, the c.d. goes downhill.
The problems are twofold, essentially: production; and pastiche.
Production-wise, with Nellie McKay, it's all about the lyrics, and too many times you can't clearly hear them. Plus, she sings flat once too often for my taste - painfully so on the d-flat of the word "there" (after "danger") on "Testify," but also throughout the otherwise-catchy "Zombie." I was going to defend Ms. McKay at the expense of the producer, except that I see she co-produced the c.d.
But when I say "pastiche," I mean a maddening mish-mash of themes, both musical and lyrical. Take "Identity Theft," for example, supposedly this c.d.'s "masterpiece." What's it about? Is Nellie saying that we lose our identity when we go to college? Or is she saying we kill our own identities with shameless self-promotion, in search of those damned 15 minutes? Or, is the truth of the matter that one night she got especially blottoed, ranted into the tape recorder in a free-association, stream of consciousness mode of thinking, and out of that, essentially unedited, came the lyrics of this song? Just a guess, but I'll put my money on that possibility. Many ideas are fine; but one gestalt, please.
As I listened and re-listened to this c.d., I thought of Frank Zappa. Not everything Zappa did was brilliant, mind you; but Zappa got to the point where he melded his peculiar brand of doo-wop, r & b, Stravinsky and Varese into one distinct voice; and his lyrics, though "subversive," were sharp and pointed. Zappa was a legend; and I'm thinking that Nellie McKay could become a similar kind of legend. But don't kid yourselves, folks; she's not there yet. But certainly, she could get there. RC
A Heart Pounder March 7, 2008
3 out of 3 found this review helpful
I never get tired of Nellie McKay. She is a delight with endless range humor, intelligence and glorious music.
Obligatory Villagers February 26, 2008
1 out of 1 found this review helpful
This is a pleasant enough CD but not as good as the previous ones ' Pretty Little Head' and the superb debut ' Get Away from Me'. Moor of the same really with an eclectic mix of styles as usual. Don;t like the first track much but unlike most CDs it gets better as it goes on. I find it a bit over orchestrated at times and there is a lack of faster tracks this time. Well worth a listen though.
Simon Fyffe
|
|
|
Copyright 2006 - CD Shopper | |
