|
| 
 enlarge | Creators: Bach, Pierre-laurent Aimard
Label: Deutsche Grammophon
Category: Music
List Price: $16.98
Buy New: $14.99
You Save: $1.99 (12%)
New (43) Used (9) from $11.06
Rating:  9 reviews
Sales Rank: 24052
Media: Audio CD
Discs: 1
Shipping Weight (lbs): 0.2
Dimensions (in): 5.7 x 4.9 x 0.4
MPN: 001076502
UPC: 028947773450
EAN: 0028947773450
ASIN: B000ZGKBYE
Release Date: March 11, 2008
Shipping: Eligible for Super Saver Shipping
Promotion: Save $10.00 when you spend $50.00 or more on Qualifying Items offered by Amazon.com. Enter code BMLSAVES at checkout. Terms and Conditions
Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours
|
| Customer Reviews:
| Showing reviews 6-9 of 9 | | « PREV | | |
 Clarity March 24, 2008
28 out of 51 found this review helpful
I am not a musicologist, but I am someone who has listened to quite a few performance of the Art of the Fugue over the last 45 years and I can say that I find the Aimard performance to be among the very best. I did carefully examine the review be Villegem and also looked, in detail, at his many other reviews. He is obviously a discerning and well informed person, but I simply find his review of this breathtaking performance, at best, academic in the worst sense of the word. If Aimard's technique fails to conform to the scholarly work of several musicologists, what difference does that really make? Can we say with certainty that that is true? I very much doubt it.
We are separated by a vast gulf of time between the writing of this music and now. Who knows how Bach would have preferred to have the Kunst der Fuge performed? Who is to say that even his conception and personal style is the best for this music? How we listen and enjoy music is very subjective. I haven't found the performances of Copland's music conducted by the composer to be the best. The same holds for Stravinsky. I do know that Aimard's performance is like light penetrating the massive complexity of this work. The end of the final fugue is truly a moment of immense and cosmic proportions. This performance is very very highly recommended.
A Bach Piano Recording For The Ages March 22, 2008
16 out of 24 found this review helpful
Those who think of Pierre-Laurent Aimard primarily as the superb interpreter of Messaien or Carter only, will be pleasantly surprised hearing his Deutsche Grammophon recording. Those of us alreadly familiar with his splendid Beethoven, Mozart and Schumann recordings for Warner Classics will not be surprised with his debut recording for Deutsche Grammophon, an utterly sublime, truly revelatory account of J. S. Bach's "Art of the Fugue". Why? In one aspect Aimard is the best current student of contemporary polyphonic music for the keyboard, and he uses that knowledge to great advantage in these performances, showing utmost respect for Bach's intentions, without trying to insert his contemporary music-informed style of performance (I strongly disagree with another reviewer who finds this recording to be excessively Romantic. Having heard many of these works performed live at Carnegie Hall by him earlier this week, they merely confirmed another strong side of his multi-faceted musical personality as a superb performing artist with a keen interest in musical scholarship too.). Without question this is one of Aimard's finest recordings, and a brilliant start to his newly cemented partnership with Deutsche Grammophon.
 Bach... to school! March 11, 2008
24 out of 77 found this review helpful
Back in October 2007 after Pierre Laurent Aimard recital in Vancouver, I wrote "The latest in that category was Pierre-Laurent Aimard... I regret to add his name to the list because he brings interesting programmes such as Messiaen 8 Preludes which he plays with basic musicality although this superb music could shine under smarter hands. However his playing Bach's Art of the Fugue was truly the most pathetic, clueless, boring and laborious exercise I have witnessed since... Murray Perahia's return to the stage! And guess what? 2008 will see a new release of that Bach monument under this very pianist! Unreal! As for Beethoven Sonata n.31, Aimard displayed a lack of structural and architectonic understanding of the piece, combined with memory lapses and little colors that was painful to hear."
Since then many on other threads have attacked my reviews. Vindication regarding the particular Bach playing came from Norman Lebrecht's recent review of the latest Aimard Gramophon "Art of the Fugue". Here are extracts of his review:
"The French pianist Pierre-Laurent Aimard will loom large in our lives in the coming year as director of the South Bank's Messiaen festival and artistic director at Aldeburgh(..). I wish I could warm more to this, his launch project. Aimard is a resourceful and dedicated pioneer of new music who brings a contemporary dimension to the classics he performs. (...) Working from a facsimile of Bach's original manuscript he applies what he describes as `alchemical' insights to the score. That's a daring claim to make and its credibility runs out somewhere around the eighth Contrapunctus when Aimard starts to weary the ear with sameness of weight and lack of colour. Like Glenn Gould, he stops dead in mid-fugue at the last note Bach wrote. Unlike Gould, he adds little to the sum of musical experience."
Of course DG is promoting the CD with a video showing the recording sessions and Aimard "alchemical" or should we say arch-comical insight: this not Bach, it's Offenbach!
His Bach playing lacks structure, articulation and often plays un-period like legatos, dynamic changes etc... Alchemy is not enough with Baroque: knowledge is the key. Lacking the structure makes PLA accentuate his performance with banging on the keyboard. The recorded sound is quite reverberent, a typical trick to mask problems. Flattering quotes of the New York Times and other newspapers are thrown in the mix so one believes it is his Bach playing that elicited them.
On another note, literally, Aimard is featured in the nonetheless excellent film by Ben Niles "Note by Note, the Making of Steinway L1037", a very well filmed documentary on the making of a concert grand. Aimard's selection process of an instrument for a Zankel Hall recital is almost farsical and his pontificating drivel prompts a good laugh! It is regrettable since he has brought such interesting repertoire from Ligeti to Messiaen to the foreground.
Extraordinary deciphering of the Code! March 11, 2008
27 out of 36 found this review helpful
I guess every Aimard-Fan will have asked twice hearing that his new album features Bach's Art of the Fugue...Aimard...playing Bach???? The same Aimard who brought us such wonderful recordings of the works of Ligeti and Messiaen and who became a highly recommended artist for the 20th century repertoire...?
But it's true and most of all: Aimard's "Kunst der Fuge" is incredible and one of the most interesting releases this year so far. By many regarded as one of the greatest enigmas in music history and as Aimard states himself in the booklet "..for a long time taken to be the height of abstraction, an untouchable object of speculation that only a few specialists were capable of deciphering...." this is exactly what Aimard does here: deciphering the code in one of the most logical ways ever recorded! The recordings of Bach's difficult work feature many interpretations on many different instruments reaching from Harpsichord to Piano or String Quartet and Orchestrations, as Bach himself never stated what instrument it was intended for. Aimard chose his own domaine the piano and by doing so reaches the height of the best recording of the work so far: Tatiana Nikolayeva's ivory tower recording which still stands out as the best. But in one way Aimard even surpasses her: In sheer logic! Never has one heard the different juxtaposition of the many counterpoints done so logically and clearly. Hearing Aimard, one has finally the impression of understanding Bach's last message.
As a minor addition the incredible warm DG sound helps a lot and the piano sounds very natural and perfectly balanced. So any pessimist out there who would never have thought that Aimard could play Bach or even come close to an interpretation of Art of the Fugue should listen to this as fast as he can and re-think his pessimism! For all Aimard fans to date one of the best discs he ever made!
|
|
|
Copyright 2006 - CD Shopper | |
